(Editor’s note: There is a recipe in here somewhere, just keep looking)

My heart hurts lately, and, among many other things, it means I don’t feel like cooking. I don’t even miss it. I don’t mind making the odd piece of toast or tossing together a salad (so long as I don’t have to chop anything), but the act of cooking — the gathering of the recipe ideas and ingredients, the paring and slicing and aromas and oils, the washing up and the serving, and relishing — gone. The main problem with that is that I feel obligated not only to this blog, to which I have committed to post recipes to an adoring public of, I think, 7, but because I do have to feed my family. For them, this lapse means they have to choke down a lot of frozen pizza and last-minute, slightly brown, omelets.
It has occurred to me that one or two of my seven readers might ask me why my heart hurts, to which I have no reply. I can say this: there are a lot of tragedies in this world, and this is not one of them. Sometimes life works out the way you hope it will — sometimes a lot better than you may have ever imagined — and sometimes it doesn’t, that’s it in a nut shell. There’s a myth, in this strange society, that we’re supposed to be happy. It is “stoic” to pretend you’re OK when you’re dying inside; you’re supposed to smile when you’re on stage, and say “I am well” when people ask how you are, because, really, they don’t want to know. I have never mastered this art of pretending. Or perhaps I have, and that’s the problem right there. Either one hurts; pretending to everyone that things are hunky hurts just as much as allowing them to glimpse your sorrow and then experience how awkward and uncomfortable it makes everyone. So, in this case, you are then supposed to either take anti-depressants, or see a therapist, or go do something proactive that ensures that the next time someone asks how you are, you are much, much better at lying.
I propose that it is OK to be sad. If you are never sad, how will you ever know when you’re happy? If you smile at someone when you don’t really mean it, how is that a smile? Wouldn’t you prefer to get a real smile, sometimes or even rarely, than a fake one every day? There are so many wonders in this world – real joys – that pretending that every day is full of them alone, to me, diminishes them; so, therefore, I get to be sad if I’m sad. And when you see me smile, you’ll know it’s real, too.
For most of my life, the cure-all for tears has been soup, particularly my grandmother’s (and my mother’s) chicken soup. I was going to write a post called “Tear Soup,” then discovered that there is a book by that name, aimed at people who are grieving. In one of my daughter’s picture books, Owl at Home, by Arnold Lobel, Owl makes “Tear Water Tea.” Of course he needs to cry in order to produce the main ingredient, so he thinks of mornings nobody saw because everybody was sleeping and pencils that are too short to use, chairs with broken legs, and books that cannot be read because some of the pages have been torn out. After enough of these sad things — spoons that have fallen behind the stove and are never seen again! – he manages to cry enough tears for one salty cup of tea. It’s a beautiful story that inspired my Tear Soup concept, except that clearly someone else felt inspired, too, so I’m no original. But that’s OK, because Grandma’s soup generally works, no matter what it’s called. The trouble is, I keep circling back to the fact that although a pot of Grandma’s soup is just what I need, I can’t bring myself to feel like making it.
I was away last week, taking care of my mother who had, among other things, a heart attack. This, in itself, merits a pot of chicken soup, but, just as I was about to drive back north, I found out that the dreaded Nora Virus had invaded the household, and there was a lot of vomiting going on, among other symptoms not fit to mention here. I made the decision to — for the first time in 15 years — not be there for the main throes of illness (in order to keep my own self healthy). You can imagine how this went down. To put it mildly, not well. So on my way home (after stopping at the pharmacy for face masks, latex gloves, and a multitude of vitamins aimed at boosting the immune system), I stopped by the food co-op and bought the ingredients for a good old fashioned pot of the best soup that I know of. I even spent over $22 on an organic free-range chicken! Donning face mask, gloves – and after a thorough, and slightly paranoid, bleach-water washdown of the kitchen – I started step-one of Grandma’s soup. The entire chicken goes into a stock pot, covered it with cold water. I then added 1/2 onion (skin still on), a couple of whole carrots, some celery stalk that I broke in half, and half a parsnip just because I happened to have one in the refrigerator. I love stock, because peeling and slicing is not necessary -in fact leaving the peels on enhances flavor. I set the burner on low, covered it, and walked away. It cooked there for hours, never boiling, barely even simmering, but eventually giving off an incredible aroma.

Now here comes the weird part: once I made the stock, I couldn’t deal with finishing the soup. I found some leftover ham and potatoes, and ended up feeding that to the family. To the sick ones, I dumped some canned chicken soup in a pot and heated it — not even caring that it boiled. All of this, even as my stock cooked in my favorite manner — low and slow — for hours. What is wrong with me? Why couldn’t I just dice some onions, slice some carrots, shred some cabbage, pick the chicken off the bone, and finish the soup? And the tragedy (aha! there is a tragedy in here after all) is that the stock turned out perfect. Yet, it sits on the bottom shelf of the refrigerator, chicken gelled into the aspicky broth, waiting to be finished. And I can’t bring myself to do it. It’s been two days now, and I can’t stand to waste a $22 chicken, so I’ll probably make it today.
This is very new for me, to be so non-committal about chicken soup, or any form of cooking for that matter. I have had moments of sheer bliss merely glimpsing through Baking with Julia; my heart soars at the market when I find the exact right ingredient; there’s not much I love more than having good friends over for dinner and having the excuse to spend days crafting a lovely meal. So NOT wanting to cook is extreme – and not wanting to cook enough to let the perfect stock linger in the fridge is unthinkable.
Meanwhile, I will do it because it’s too much of a sin not to. And, when I sip the wonderful flavors, I will be glad. When my family gobbles it down, I may be even gladder. And to think, it all hearkens back to Edna Goldner, mistress of the soup – craftily adding ingredients on the sly so we never could know exactly what she put into it. I find myself wanting to hope (but not quite hoping) that a nice bowl of the stuff might put one of those authentic smiles on my face. I suspect though, that it will remind me of my beloved Grandma and I will close my eyes as the wholesomeness of the ingredients does its magic, and, very slowly, I’ll start to feel better.
Edna Goldner’s Chicken Soup
(with huge ammendments made by her granddaughter)
Notes: Do this on a day when you will be around the house for many hours; do not worry so much about amounts and be flexible with your ingredients. As always, use what you have.
Ingredients:
- 1 whole chicken (I used a ‘young’ chicken but I suspect the original recipe used up an old cock – please no jokes!)
- 2 onions
- many carrots
- as much celery as you like
- either parsnip or parsley (or both) grandma was never clear on this point
- garlic (not traditional, so play it by your own taste)
- salt and pepper to taste
- Optional:
- Greens such as shredded cabbage or kale
- rice or noodles or matzoh balls on the side (never mix in with the soup in the pot).
Directions: Cover the whole chicken with cold water in a large, heavy bottomed stock pot. Halve the onion, a couple of the carrots and 2 stalks celery, add to the pot. Add parsnip or parsley if you like. Set on a low heat, cover, and leave it alone for at least 3 hours. When the chicken is cooked through, take it off the pot and let cool. Drain the stock into a large bowl. Toss the vegetables; keep the chicken. Dice or slice the remaining onions, carrots and celery (and any other vegetables you may want in your soup) and toss with 1 T of the chicken fat skimmed from the top of the soup (in the same stockpot in which the stock cooked). After 4 – 5 minutes, add the stock back in. Cook vegetables until soft; meanwhile remove chicken from bones and shred or cut into small pieces and set aside in a bowl. If you want rice, noodles or matzoh balls, make them and also set aside in a bowl. (Do not add the chicken and the starch to the soup; doing so will cause the meat to lose flavor, and the starches to swell up and take up much of your broth). Rather, when the soup is ready to eat; add the amount of rice and chicken you want to your bowl, then pour the soup over it. The heat of the soup will heat up the rice and chicken. Sprinkle with chopped parsley if desired. Salt and pepper to taste. Enjoy. May it heal you and fill your belly with love and nutrition.
